Detecting and resolving conflicts (at generation time)

While you prepare a timetable, Omniscol flags conflicts and shows their severity with a color. For the results of automatic generation, see Diagnosing a failed generation.

Where alerts appear

  • On the grid. Each candidate time slot takes the color of the most serious problem that placing a lesson there would create. See Manual placement.
  • In the selection lists. When you choose a teacher, a classroom, a resource, a group or participants, a calendar icon shows the severity of the problems at the lesson's time slot. Hover over the icon to see the details.
  • In the diagnostic panel. The panel evaluates after the fact the lessons that were created, whether placed or not: conflicts between lessons, gaps in planned hours. It also flags, even before the first lesson, a missing or inconsistent setting, such as a site without a grid or a group in several alignments.

Some detections serve all three places, such as a teacher's occupancy or a time constraint. Others only make sense after the fact, such as grid overflow. The table of detections shows the screens concerned and the level of each alert.

Conflicts with another timetable

In the Timetable management module, in reorganization as when editing a calendar timetable, the diagnostic also checks the timetable against the other timetables published on the same dates and against linked accounts: those ticked in the Synchronization menu. A teacher, a class or a room already taken in one of them creates a conflict, even when the current timetable has no other lesson at that time.

In the details of the conflict, a lesson from another timetable shows, after its class name, the icon followed by the label of that timetable. A lesson from a linked account shows the icon followed by the name of that account. Omniscol recognizes the same class, room or resource across timetables by its external identifier, otherwise by its name: see recognizing the same class across timetables.

Severity levels

Candidate time slots and selection lists use four colors.

Color Meaning
green no conflict — the entity is free (or a resource stays under its limit)
yellow minor, non-blocking inconvenience (medium-priority time constraint, fully substituted absence, acceptable but not ideal classroom)
orange strong constraint (high-priority time constraint, classroom filled up to 110% of its capacity, service hours up to 110%, travel between sites too short, incompatible subjects, closed day)
red blocking conflict (double-booking of a teacher, a class or a classroom, resource whose units are all taken, mandatory time constraint or imposed date window, classroom beyond 110% of its capacity, uncovered absence, broken alignment)

In the diagnostic panel. Each listed problem carries a level, reused by the filter. The panel groups orange and yellow under a single “important” level, and adds an “advice” level for non-blocking information:

Level Meaning Matching slot colors
red Blocking conflict red
yellow Unmet constraint / Warning orange + yellow, and red between lessons that are all locked
blue Advice / Near limit grid pressure, class divisions

The Premium option Block conflicting choices (hard constraints) blocks the time slots and choices flagged by a red conflict. When the option is off, these alerts help you decide whether to keep the choice. A classroom that is too small, wrongly specialized or located on another site can remain selectable, with a warning on its label.

Grid overflow and pressure

Omniscol compares the lesson hours to place with the hours available in the grid, for each class and for each teacher, per class and per site. The alert shows both values, for example “18 h / 16 h”.

Threshold Fill level Reading
blue — pressure over 90% and up to 100% little room is left to place the lessons
orange — slight overflow over 100% and up to 110% the hours to place exceed the capacity of the grid
red — heavy overflow over 110% the excess is more than 10% of the capacity of the grid

The computation applies as soon as at least one site is configured.

Detections by screen

A check mark shows where the alert appears. The Level column specifies its severity depending on the screen.

Detection Grid Lists Panel Elsewhere Level
Teacher, class or group already busy with another lesson or an event ✓ ✓ teachers, groups ✓ Occupancy conflicts red
Classroom already occupied by another lesson or an event ✓ if a classroom is assigned ✓ classrooms ✓ Occupancy conflicts red
Shared classroom whose maximum number of classes is exceeded ✓ ✓ classrooms ✓ Capacity red
Resource whose units are all already taken ✓ ✓ resources ✓ Capacity red
Teacher, class, classroom or resource already taken in another published timetable or a linked account (see above) ✓ ✓ classrooms, resources ✓ Occupancy conflicts; resource: Capacity same as occupancy
Broken alignment (aligned groups without a shared lesson) ✓ ✓ groups ✓ Occupancy conflicts diagnostic table of groups red; orange if only the classroom, the resource or the videoconference link differs
Unmet time constraint (teacher, class, group, classroom, subject, site, opening hours) ✓ ✓ teachers, classrooms, groups ✓ Availability mandatory → red, high → orange, medium → yellow; date window → always red
Insufficient travel time between two sites (teacher, class) ✓ ✓ teachers ✓ Distance between sites orange
Incompatible subjects at the same time ✓ ✓ Incompatibility of subjects orange
No suitable classroom free at the time slot, although at least one classroom of the site fits ✓ ✓ Lesson fixed without classroom yellow; red if no classroom is free
No teacher of the subject free at the time slot, or too few for the lessons that need one at this time slot ✓ ✓ Lesson without teacher yellow
Teacher absent from their lesson ✓ ✓ teachers lesson hover not covered → red, co-teaching partly covered → orange, substituted → yellow
Class absent ✓ ✓ groups lesson hover red
Lesson on a holiday ✓ lesson hover orange
More students than seats in the classroom ✓ classrooms, on the capacity label ✓ Capacity orange, red beyond a 10% excess
Classroom wrongly specialized or on another site ✓ classrooms, on the label, always selectable orange or red
Teacher's service hours exceeded ✓ teachers ✓ table of teachers list: orange, red beyond 10%; table: orange if they differ, red beyond the service hours or more than 10% below
Missing teacher: lesson without a teacher, unless No teacher was chosen or its modality is self study ✓ Lesson without teacher yellow
Missing classroom: lesson placed without a classroom, unless No classroom was chosen or its modality is remote or self study ✓ Lesson fixed without classroom yellow
Grid overflow / pressure ✓ at the top of the panel blue → orange → red (see above)
A class's maximum hours per day or per week exceeded ✓ at the top of the panel warning
Gap between the hours planned for a subject and those of its lessons ✓ table of classes red if no hours or if the total exceeds the planned volume, orange if the total is lower
Gap between the hours planned for a teacher in a class and those of their lessons ✓ table of teachers per class orange
Group without a lesson ✓ table of groups orange
Deviation from a subject's hours allocation policy (Premium), including when a lesson's duration, group, teacher or classroom differs from what is planned ✓ Hours allocation policy indicator on the subject, in a class's courses yellow in the panel and orange on the indicator up to a 10% deviation, red beyond
Different number or duration of lessons between groups of a class division ✓ Different number of lessons for groups in class division blue (informational)
Unequal hours between the groups of a class division, in a subject indicator on the subject, in a class's courses orange; in its detail, the total of a group with no hours is red
Different lessons between aligned groups (number, subject, duration, teacher, classroom or placement) ✓ Different lessons for groups in alignment red (blocking configuration)
Group in several alignments ✓ configuration red
Specialization requested with no matching classroom on the class's site ✓ configuration red
Subject of a group of groups missing from one of its classes ✓ groups: the group of groups is not offered ✓ configuration yellow
Incomplete configuration (site, classroom, grid, lesson) ✓ configuration blocking before generation
Missing videoconference link although the lesson's modality (remote, hybrid) requires one warning icon and message on the lesson orange
No classroom of the site meets a need of the lesson, or none is large enough lesson editing orange; red if no suitable classroom reaches the minimum number of seats, whether the need is mandatory or not
Duration of a time slot, excluding the lunch break, too far from the nearest multiple of the reference duration generation screen, site editing yellow if the deviation exceeds 25% of the reference duration. Red if it exceeds 40%, or if at least 60% of the checked slots exceed the 25% threshold
Placed lesson that ends after the last slot of the grid generation screen yellow
A classroom's occupancy rate (students against its capacity) classrooms dashboard red beyond 100%, orange at 25% or less
More students enrolled than the class's declared headcount classes dashboard red
A student's share of absences students dashboard on the rounded percentage: blue from 6 to 10%, yellow from 11 to 15%, orange from 16 to 20%, red beyond 20%

The panel leaves out alerts related to absences and holidays, because a lesson may be placed deliberately during an absence or on a holiday.

When an alert shows a magnifier , click it to open its details. You can then go to the lesson concerned from those details. For a group conflict (class division, alignment), the Only view groups related to this group icon keeps only the related groups, which makes the constraint stand out when the raw diagnostic is not enough.

Filtering the diagnostic: on Premium accounts, the diagnostic panel can be filtered by level, entity, class level, campus, site, problem type or date interval to isolate what matters.

Filtering the diagnostic

The Diagnostic filters button (warning triangle, at the top of the panel) opens a menu to keep only the alerts useful to the current analysis. Its icon turns orange while a filter remains active. It lets you set:

  • Levels — show or hide red (blocking), yellow (important / to check), blue (advice / near limit).
  • Entities — classes, teachers, classrooms, resources, groups, and the calendar event types (events, holidays, absences).
  • Class levels, campuses, sites — restrict to a scope. A campus isolates an organizational entity (branch, faculty, division); a site refers to the physical location.
  • Reasons — enable or disable each detection family: occupancy conflicts, availability, lesson without teacher, lesson fixed without classroom, capacity, distance between sites, incompatibility of subjects, different number of lessons for groups in class division, different lessons for groups in alignment, hours allocation policy.
  • Interval (calendar timetables) — limit to the next weeks or months, and hide the past.
  • Behavior — Block conflicting choices (hard constraints) actively prevents placements that would create a strong conflict.
  • Reset — show everything again.

A filter does not resolve a conflict: it only hides what does not help the current analysis.

Resolving a conflict

The most frequent fixes are:

  • moving a lesson;
  • changing the teacher, classroom or resource;
  • adjusting a constraint that is too strong;
  • correcting an unavailability or an absence entered by mistake;
  • creating or fixing the groups, class divisions or alignments;
  • adding a compatible classroom, a capacity or a specialization;
  • locking a lesson that must stay fixed before rerunning a generation.

If generation does not find a complete solution, it can return a partial timetable: the unplaced lessons remain in the sticky notes bar of lessons to place. Fix the priority diagnostics, then rerun or manually position the remaining cases.

Cases that call for a decision

Some signals correspond to a management decision rather than a data-entry error. Examples:

  • an exam with a main room and an extra-time room;
  • a capacity declared above the seats entered when the institution knows that some of the enrolled will not be present;
  • an annex room not modeled in Omniscol.

In these cases, it is better to model the situation explicitly when possible: multi-room, adapted groups, a corrected capacity or a separate event. Leaving a deliberate alert must remain a decision known to the team, not permanent noise.

How-to

  1. Open the timetable's diagnostic.
  2. If needed, filter by level, campus, site, entity or problem type.
  3. Handle the blocking conflicts first.
  4. Open the details of the problem to identify the lessons and resources involved.
  5. Fix the lesson, the constraint or the modeling.
  6. Rerun the diagnostic or the generation to check that the problem is gone.

See also